March 06, 2006

Para Los Niņos

Some unsolicited advice for the pro-life crowd:

If criminalizing abortion is really all about saving precious little babies, then make that case. Don't instead let creepmeister Bill Napoli start talking:

FRED DE SAM LAZARO: Napoli says most abortions are performed for what he calls "convenience." He insists that exceptions can be made for rape or incest under the provision that protects the mother's life. I asked him for a scenario in which an exception may be invoked.

BILL NAPOLI: A real-life description to me would be a rape victim, brutally raped, savaged. The girl was a virgin. She was religious. She planned on saving her virginity until she was married. She was brutalized and raped, sodomized as bad as you can possibly make it, and is impregnated. I mean, that girl could be so messed up, physically and psychologically, that carrying that child could very well threaten her life.

. . . because, see, what happens is, I read filth like that--and are you sensing a inordinately gleeful tone to Bill's description, there? Because I am--and the counterargument, the counterargument that antiabortionists aren't nearly so much about saving precious little babies as they are about morally policing grown women; you know, that counterargument?--It becomes extremely difficult for me to refute. Impossible, actually.

Remember, ladies: It's only rape if you're a virgin who gets it up the ass. No anal?--No rape. Sorry. Them's the rules, and I learned them the same way I'm certain in my bones that Mr. Napoli did: From porn.

Incidentally, it's interesting to me that some of the comments about this have expressed puzzlement at Napoli's inclusion of sodomy in his--let's call it what it is, now--rape fantasy.

What's to be puzzled about? If you take the view that a woman is merely a life-support system for a (all right, you know I don't like that word) and, also, that this object exists purely for the pleasure of men, it follows that uninvited intrusions into said object can't possibly cause trauma, or even occur in the first place, because who, exactly, would they traumatize? Who would fail to invite them, who would consider it intrusion? The owner? But that's ridiculous--there is no owner. It's funny how when it comes to the pussy so many men are inherently communist, no matter how they vote on matters political.

Anyway, you can't violate property rights if no one owns the property. There is no owner. There's merely this mouth that flaps up and down on its own accord for no discernible reason at times (you should slap it if the noise annoys you) and, oh yeah, these parts that make babies--but those belong to men too, so, you're all set. It's all good.

So there's no crime here. Bone that gadget all you like, hombres; it is yours, unless it is God's. And don't worry: If in fact it is God's, you'll find out just as soon as that goofy mouth attached way up yonder asks you to kill it rather than borrow it. Feel free to disregard that request, though, same as you disregard anything else you don't want to hear coming out of it. Besides, it might be lying. Did you feel a hymen break? No? All right, then. Clearly it's okay to go where others have been before you.

But anal--ah, a man can relate to anal. That's what he'd call rape were he on the receiving end of it, and you know what, I think I'll repent later for wishing right now that Napoli someday finds himself in just exactly that position.

As bad as you could possibly make it.

(Via I Blame the Patriarchy.)

Posted by Ilyka at March 6, 2006 03:27 PM in news
Comments

If I were a conspiracy-minded paranoiac I'd almost think the pro-life movement has been seeded with mole "hardliners" for purposes of sabotage. Fortunately I am instead an observer of human nature, and know that it's just always the cruddiest specimens that get the focus. The pro-abortion side has equally interesting creatures like that woman who culled two of her three fetuses because she didn't want to shop at Costco.

Posted by: Andrea Harris at March 6, 2006 04:21 PM
like that woman who culled two of her three fetuses because she didn't want to shop at Costco

Right; I think I brought her up in the comments here, in fact. Last I looked, however, she wasn't so much a pro-choice activist (and certainly she wasn't a lawmaker) as she was simply a garden-variety "what-about-my-lifestyle" yuppie.

The Me Generation: Did it ever really die?

My problem with Napoli is twofold, but still simple: First, he's a skeeze. I wouldn't let him around any daughters I had, that's certain. But second, he makes people who are genuinely pro-life look, to the other side, like mere useful idiots. If I were determinedly pro-life, I'd find statements like his insulting and definitely unhelpful.

Posted by: ilyka at March 7, 2006 02:40 AM

You skipped his other major criteria. A girl must also be religious in order to be raped. Not religious? Then it's not rape. No abortion for you.

A skeeze? Hell, he's a genuine fucktard.

Posted by: Jim at March 7, 2006 03:37 AM

Well, count me as a pro-lifer who finds this guy's comments repulsive. Leave it to the media to always find the most embarrassing people possible to represent the pro-life side.

There was a thread on Dawn Eden's blog about this last week. There are lots of poised, intelligent, articulate women who could speak for the pro-life side. (And I do think having a woman speak would lend a lot more credibility. Nothing against pro-life men, that's just the way it is.) But the media always finds some yahoo with a bad toupee or someone who gives off strong perv vibes like this Napoli guy.

Posted by: Susan B. at March 7, 2006 08:19 AM
But the media always finds some yahoo with a bad toupee or someone who gives off strong perv vibes like this Napoli guy.

I think it's fair to point out that the media didn't hunt down some obscure dude to put pro-life folks in a bad light; Napoli is a South Dakota Senator who spoke in favor of HB1215 during debate on the law.

Posted by: Hubris at March 7, 2006 10:31 AM
Hell, he's a genuine fucktard.

Indeed. A candidate for the SBD Flaming Asshole Award if ever there was.

Posted by: ilyka at March 7, 2006 03:25 PM

Hubris,

Point well taken. Still, I wish this Senator had not embarrassed pro-lifers like this.

Posted by: Susan B. at March 7, 2006 06:08 PM

"It's funny how when it comes to the pussy so many men are inherently communist, no matter how they vote on matters political."

Until they become fathers of female children and sort of own one by proxy for a few years (I mean the younger years when you are really wholly responsible for a child's welfare). Changes the perspective of anyone who's got a shred of decency. I hope to Christ Napoli doesn't have daughters, because if he does, he's beyond redemption.

Posted by: John at March 8, 2006 07:03 AM